|
|
|
|
|
Canadian Tax Software
By: Walter Metcalf
Date: 03/28/01
Tax time, like the annual 'flu season, has arrived once again. However, unlike the 'flu, we can do more than get our
shot, and then simply wait and hope. Taking advantage of the speed of modern personal computers, there are a number
of excellent tax software packages, which are easy to use, accurate, and make sure you get every deduction
to which you are entitled. In fact, the new breed of software allow you to file your tax return right after you've
prepared it without ever leaving your computer! This process is called NETFILE'ing, and I'll elaborate on it later.
Because I am a Canadian, I am only familiar with the Canadian Income Tax system, so I've only examined Canadian Tax software
in this article. Testing Canadian software has also given me the advantage of actually filing some returns (or trying to),
using these software packages, something I would find difficult to do using U.S. Tax Software, for example.
Unfortunately the Canadian OS/2 user is at a considerable disadvantage. Every single tax program, save one, requires Windows in order to run. That one--
GriffTax--is a MacIntosh program, and Gates owns a sizable portion
of Apple. However, the facts that really grated on me, and showed further evidence of Gates' control were the two
browser tax programs I tried. First, let me point out that Canada Customs and Revenue Agency (CCRA) does have a browser
test, but all it tests for is 128-bit encryption, and Netscape for OS/2 v4.61 passes with flying colours. However the
file-by-browser style "programs" either rejected the
latest Netscape version for OS/2 v.4.61 without comment (U-File), or require that you download Windows versions of other
programs such as Acrobat and QuickTime (QuickTax Web). There are OS/2 versions of Acrobat and QuickTime. In fact to play
videos, the user could use several programs, including RealPlayer, which runs under Odin.
This requirement of additional Windows programs, and arbitrarily rejecting all but certain versions of Internet Explorer
and Netscape is designed for nothing but to give Microsoft control over how we file our taxes. Fortunately, as we shall see,
there is still one tax software manufacturer that has not completely bent the knee to Bill Gates. In addition Odin continues
to make progress; perhaps next year it will run one of the other products.
Finally, one more thing before we compare the various products.
This year, for the first time CCRA, formerly Revenue Canada, has opened its NETFILE program to everyone. However there are
a few restrictions. Some returns are ineligible for NETFILE'ing. To find out if you are eligible, check this
list. Essentially, this program is both an extension and a
restriction to the EFILE system, which allows eligible professional tax preparers to transmit tax returns for their clients
to the government over the Internet. NETFILE differs from EFILE in that 1) in principle, every taxpayer is eligible to
NETFILE. No special registration is required; and 2) an individual can only NETFILE his own return.
Canadian Tax Software from the OS/2 User's Perspective
Notes:
|
CanTax
|
CoolTax
|
QuickTax
|
TaxWiz
|
U-File
|
Version Tested
|
T1Plus
|
CoolTax
|
QuickTax
|
TaxWiz
|
UFile
|
Publisher
|
CCH Ltd.
|
FLS Research
|
Intuit
|
Taxmatic
|
Dr. Tax
|
NETFILE certified?
|
yes
|
yes
|
yes
|
yes
|
yes
|
Base price (for
download
version,
where available)
|
$795
|
$10
|
$24.95
|
24.95
|
$12.95
|
DOS compatible?
|
no
|
no
|
no
|
no
|
no
|
WinOS2 compatible?
|
no
|
no
|
yes; however
required update
was not
|
yes
|
no
|
OS/2 compatible
(using Odin)?
|
no (install failed)
|
no (Active X is
required, which
is not yet sup-
ported by Odin)
|
no (installer
wouldn't start)
|
N.A.
|
no - U-File
is a browser
product and
didn't accept
the latest
version of
Netscape
for
OS/2 4.61
|
Support Options
|
Web; newsletter;
CanTax agents,
some of whom
have toll-free
numbers.
|
web site, incl. FAQ;
telephone
|
web site, phone
(I've had several
reports of very
long waits)
|
web site FAQ;
telephone (my
only reader said
there was no
delay); email
support--
2,3 day wait
|
|
Special Features
|
1)Built-in Links to
CCH Reference
Materials--the
ultimate in
professional tax
reference material.
|
"Family Coupling"
feature prepares
returns for a
family simulta-
neously, optimizing
deductions on-the-
fly.
|
|
Taxmatic is
committed to
keeping TaxWiz
Win 3.1
compatible, at
least through
2002.
|
|
COMMENTS:
- Since TaxWiz will be available for Windows 3.1, and therefore will probably run under WinOS2, next year,
it is very likely I will use that product to do my family's 2001 taxes.
- However, CoolTax is a strong runner-up, and if TaxWiz is not available for OS/2 after all, or if Odin is
improved to the point where it will properly run CoolTax, then I will look very hard at that as option.
Here's why:
- Price, although $15 is not a big deal;
- CoolTax is really just TaxByte in a different
suit of clothes. TaxByte is a full-blown professional preparer software package that has
been in existence for 13 years and is used annually by thousands of preparers. Consequently,
CoolTax is more sophisticated and is less likely to have errors in the tax engine than the
versions that exist only in a "lite" form.
- No browser-based products except U-File were tested.
- The QuickTax CD does contain a Windows 3.1, WinOS2 compatible, version of the product. However there is no
Windows 3.1-compatible of the update required both to incorporate last fall's budget, and to enable NETFILE'ing.
Moreover, the output of Windows 3.1 QuickTax product cannot be used as input by the 32-bit version of the product.
Walter Metcalf
For Further Reading: QuickTax Basic Tax Year 2000 From OS/2 e-Zine by Robert Basler Unfortunately, as mentioned in the COMMENTS, Intuit let the product die for OS/2 users by failing to provide a Windows 3.1 version of the update. Tax Solutions for U.S. OS/2 Users From OS/2 e-Zine by Mark Dodel Mark reviews two U.S. tax products.
Unless otherwise noted, all content on this site is Copyright © 2004, VOICE
|
|
|
|
|
|
|